Yahoo Japan news editor says his own staff tend to pander to readers

Darth Demon

Contributor/Visitor
Apr 2, 2007
299
8
Yahoo Japan news editor says his own staff tend to pander to readers

Source: Japantoday.com Article

"TOKYO — The editor-in-chief of online news provided by Yahoo Japan Corp lamented a ‘‘dangerous trend’’ among its own newsroom staff to pander to readers in picking articles, which often results in ignoring newsworthy items that may not earn much traffic.

Michihiro Okumura, 40, head of the influential online news section, told the Japan National Press Club recently that about 20 Yahoo Japan employees who select news items from among some 3,500 articles offered daily by around 150 media organizations can be ‘‘tempted to cater to readers’ needs and often choose sports and entertainment news.’’

Yahoo Japan does not report news by itself, but distributes articles under eight categories such as domestic, international, business, sports and entertainment. The site run by former newspaper and television reporters attracts about 60 million readers and earns 3.76 billion page views per month, according to Okumura.

The former Yomiuri Shimbun reporter said the most-read articles are generally gossip and about 60% of all news items viewed by readers per month consist of entertainment, sports and crime news in Japan. Usually, international news items draw little interest, he said.

Unlike traditional media, online news covers issues of both public and personal interests and the great strength of Internet news is that viewers can personalize news items, or choose articles that will suit their own personal interests, the news section chief said.

However, online news sites should keep in mind that news items are not just commercial goods but also valuable tools to change society, Okumura said, urging both news organizations and portal sites to ‘‘carry out social responsibility.’’

Okumura aired concerns that in 10 years’ time, a gap in the intellectual level may be widening between people who can afford subscription to quality media services and those who just click Internet news sites and read only gossip and sports news.

He said nowadays, rival Internet sites employ automatic searching technique in selecting news items but that he believes human newsroom staff should have an edge in certain areas."
 

Sakunyuusha

New Member
Jan 27, 2008
1,855
3
This is one more battlefield in the war between specificity and generality. What I mean to say is, the media are no different than commercial stores: they have a product to sell (in this case, the product is information about the state of the world), and they have a choice to make: "do we specialize or don't we?" Do they cater towards a niche audience or do they aim for the entire market audience?

The problem for the media, one shared with them by other industries in the commercial sector, is that the public is fickle: it see-saws back and forth between the two extremes every now and again. Today, the wind blows in one direction and everybody says, "I'm tired of subscribing to 10 different newspapers. I just want to get one newspaper that covers everything." But fast-forward a few years and that same person will complain that his one subscription is doing a poorer job at covering sports stories than the sports-only newspaper does; or that its World News section is abysmal and that if he wants to really know what's happening in China right now he has to subscribe to a Chinese newspaper instead. So on and so on and so forth.

If Yahoo News has decided that they want to be an all-purpose source of news, then yes, what's happening is "bad" and it should no longer be allowed to continue. But if Yahoo News should decide instead to "be the #1 source for the stories the public cares most about," then that's fine, too. It's their business, and they should run it however they see fit. People who are concerned that Yahoo News is no longer doing a good job reporting "serious news" and is wasting valuable manpower on the reporting of unimportant news like high school soccer and college basketball need not be so upset: there are dozens of fish in the sea, and it's quite easy to say good-bye to Yahoo News and to say hello to a new source of world news.